The predictive power of the number, and its scale
The meta-analysis published in JAMA in 2009 pools 33 studies, 102,980 participants and 6,910 deaths. Each one-MET step up in aerobic capacity, about 1 km/h more running speed, is associated with 13 percent lower all-cause mortality and 15 percent fewer coronary or cardiovascular events.
Participants with low capacity, below 7.9 METs, have a mortality risk 1.70 times higher than those with high capacity. Even compared with the intermediate group, they remain at 1.40. The 7.9 METs threshold, about 28 mL/kg/min, marks the clearest boundary in this literature.
The largest series is from the Cleveland Clinic: 122,007 patients tested on a treadmill, 13,637 deaths over 1.1 million person-years. Compared with the least fit group, below the 25th percentile, the elite group has an 80 percent lower mortality risk. Read the other way, the least fit group dies 5.04 times more.
There is no threshold beyond which being fitter stops helping
This study had been set up to answer a precise concern: the idea that very sustained training would eventually harm the heart. The data say the opposite. The elite group, above the 97.7th percentile, keeps an advantage over the simply very fit group (hazard ratio 0.77).
In other words, the curve does not turn around. That is useful to know when a 55-year-old hesitates to start seriously again because they read that beyond a certain point sport damages the body.
These data come from patients referred for an exercise test, therefore from an already medically monitored population. They do not extrapolate without caution to the general population, but the consistency with the 2009 meta-analysis is strong.
The American Heart Association treats it as a vital sign
In 2016, the American Heart Association published a position statement whose title says the essentials: cardiorespiratory fitness should be assessed in clinical practice, like a vital sign. Blood pressure, heart rate, and fitness.
The reasoning is one of prediction. None of the classic risk factors separates people as well, and none is as modifiable. A patient does not change their age or their heredity. Their fitness, yes.
It is also what makes this marker interesting for a non-physician practitioner: it is measured without a prescription, followed over time, and it informs on the trajectory rather than on a snapshot.
How much this number moves with training
The meta-analysis of controlled trials published in Sports Medicine in 2015 quantifies the gain. Endurance training improves VO2 max by 4.9 mL/kg/min compared with a group without exercise. High-intensity interval training improves it by 5.5 mL/kg/min.
Compared directly with continuous endurance, intervals gain only 1.2 mL/kg/min, a gap the authors describe as small. The hierarchy between the two methods is therefore clearly less important than the gap between training and not training.
Two elements increase the gain in both approaches: starting from low fitness, and keeping the program longer. These are the two most frequent conditions in people who consult.
The non-responder idea fares poorly against long intervals
It is often said that some people do not progress, whatever they do. The meta-analysis published in PLoS One in 2013 reviewed 37 interval training studies, 334 participants, and finds a mean gain of 0.51 L/min in VO2 max.
In the subset of nine studies using long intervals, 72 participants, the gain rises to 0.8 to 0.9 L/min, and the authors note a marked response in all subjects. The conclusion they draw: the notion of non-responder depends largely on the protocol used.
An important precision: these works concern sedentary or moderately active adults under 45. They do not transpose as they stand to a 70-year-old, and interval protocols require prior medical referral when there is a cardiovascular history.
The only long randomized trial showed no mortality benefit
This is the element people forget to cite. The Norwegian Generation 100 trial randomized 1,567 people aged 70 to 77 between three arms for five years: high-intensity intervals twice a week, moderate continuous training, or a simple instruction to follow national recommendations.
Result: all-cause mortality does not differ between the control group and the trained groups combined. Separating the arms, the absolute risk reduction is 1.7 points with intervals (hazard ratio 0.63, confidence interval 0.33 to 1.20), therefore not significant.
The explanation lies partly in the control group: it started moving more than expected. This does not invalidate the interest of fitness, but it sets an honest limit. The relationship between VO2 max and mortality is very robust in observation, and a single long trial did not manage to demonstrate it by randomization.
Estimating without a laboratory, and the reliability of the estimate
A direct measurement requires a mask, a gas analyzer and a maximal protocol. Few practitioners have access to it, and few clients need it. Available estimates are of two kinds: field tests with increasing load, and connected watch estimates.
Watch estimates have a known flaw: they rest on the relationship between heart rate and speed, so they drift as soon as heart rate is disturbed by heat, sleep, alcohol or a bradycardic medication. As with sleep sensors, a device's number can only be interpreted against its own history.
For monitoring, what matters is not the absolute value but the slope. A person who gains 3 mL/kg/min in four months has changed risk category, whatever the tool that measured it, provided it is the same tool at the start and at the end.
The clearest gain happens in the least fit
The largest gain happens in the least fit people, and both meta-analyses say it explicitly. This is the opposite of the usual intuition, which would have a beginner progress little.
The real constraint is therefore not the choice between endurance and intervals, it is regularity over several months, since program duration is the other factor that increases the gain. A perfect protocol kept for six weeks does less than an average protocol kept for six months.
Finally, cardiorespiratory fitness and strength are two distinct qualities, carried by different adaptations. Progressing on one does not exempt from working on the other, and World Health Organization recommendations ask for both.
Sources
- 1.Kodama S, et al. Cardiorespiratory fitness as a quantitative predictor of all-cause mortality and cardiovascular events in healthy men and women: a meta-analysis. JAMA. 2009.
- 2.Mandsager K, et al. Association of Cardiorespiratory Fitness With Long-term Mortality Among Adults Undergoing Exercise Treadmill Testing. JAMA Netw Open. 2018.
- 3.Ross R, et al. Importance of Assessing Cardiorespiratory Fitness in Clinical Practice: A Case for Fitness as a Clinical Vital Sign. Circulation. 2016.
- 4.Milanović Z, et al. Effectiveness of High-Intensity Interval Training and Continuous Endurance Training for VO2max Improvements: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Sports Med. 2015.
- 5.Bacon AP, et al. VO2max trainability and high intensity interval training in humans: a meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2013.
- 6.Stensvold D, et al. Effect of exercise training for five years on all cause mortality in older adults, the Generation 100 study: randomised controlled trial. BMJ. 2020.
- 7.Wewege M, et al. The effects of high-intensity interval training vs. moderate-intensity continuous training on body composition in overweight and obese adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Obes Rev. 2017.
- 8.Bull FC, et al. World Health Organization 2020 guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour. Br J Sports Med. 2020.
Reading studies is one thing, turning them into a plan is another
The Longevity Practitioner certification teaches the method that turns this kind of data into an accompaniment decision: assess, prioritise, plan over 90 days, re-measure, and know when to hand over.
11 modules, €2,200. Enrol
Continue reading
Benjamin Sant
Co-founder of the School of Longevity
Cofounder of the School of Longevity with Tristan Maruyama. A former officer trained at Saint-Cyr from 2019 to 2022 and a coach since 2018, he has supported more than 4,000 people. He leads the School's editorial content with one constant principle: pass on only what can be situated, verified and applied seriously.
This article is published for information and education. It does not replace medical advice. For any personal health question, consult a healthcare professional.
