A questionnaire rules out, it does not quantify
A screening instrument is judged on two numbers. Sensitivity says how well it avoids missing the people concerned. Negative predictive value says what a reassuring result is worth. Good first consultation questionnaires are sensitive and not very specific: they let many false positives through and miss few true cases.
This dictates their use. A low score reasonably rules out a hypothesis and allows moving on. A high score concludes nothing at all: it only indicates that a question remains open, and most often that it falls outside the scope of the person who asked it.
The usual confusion is to read these scores as measurements. A number from a questionnaire is not a quantity, it is a shifted probability. The rest of this article shows how far that gap can go, particularly on physical activity and diet.
Sleep: two instruments, two different questions
The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index, published in 1989, remains the reference tool for sleep complaints. Nineteen items give seven component scores, perceived quality, sleep latency, duration, efficiency, disturbances, medication, daytime dysfunction, then a global score. Above 5, it separated good and poor sleepers with a sensitivity of 89.6 percent and a specificity of 86.5 percent, for a kappa of 0.75.
The STOP-Bang questionnaire answers another question, that of sleep apnea. A meta-analysis of seventeen studies and 9,206 patients finds, in a sleep clinic population, a sensitivity of 90 percent, 94 percent and 96 percent for mild, moderate to severe and severe apnea. The probability of severe apnea rises steadily with the score: 25 percent at 3 points, 35 at 4, 45 at 5, 55 at 6, 75 at 7 or 8.
A third tool circulates widely and should not be used for this. A meta-analysis of 108 studies and 47,989 participants gives, for mild apnea, a sensitivity of 88 percent for STOP-Bang and 87 percent for STOP, against 54 percent for the Epworth sleepiness scale. Epworth measures daytime sleepiness, not apnea risk, and a person who is not sleepy can perfectly well have apnea.
Declared activity is not the activity performed
The International Physical Activity Questionnaire is the most used in the world. Its 2003 validation, conducted in fourteen centers in twelve countries, shows good reproducibility, with a Spearman rho around 0.8 between two administrations in the same week. But validity against the accelerometer falls to a median rho of about 0.30.
A Canadian comparison from 2015 shows the size of the problem plainly. In 112 adults wearing an accelerometer at least ten hours a day for four days, the correlation with the IPAQ was 0.20. Above all, 90 percent of respondents met the activity recommendations according to their own statements, against 29 percent according to the accelerometer when counting bouts of at least ten minutes.
This gap is not anecdotal, because it is measured activity that predicts. In NHANES 2011-2014, on 3,653 people aged 50 to 80 and 416 deaths, the three best single predictors of all-cause mortality were all activity indices from the accelerometer, the best reaching a C of 0.697, ahead of age at 0.676. An activity questionnaire opens the conversation, it does not conclude that a person moves enough.
Five questions to spot muscle frailty
The SARC-F fits in five items: strength, help with walking, rising from a chair, climbing stairs, falls. It was built in 2016 on three cohorts, including the Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging and NHANES.
A score of 4 or more went with more limitations in instrumental activities of daily living, a slower chair stand, weaker grip strength, a walking speed below 0.8 m/s and recent hospitalization. Over six years of follow-up, it was also associated with mortality.
The practical interest lies in its place in the session. Five questions asked in two minutes say whether to take out the dynamometer and time a walk, or whether consultation time is better used elsewhere. It does not diagnose sarcopenia, it decides the next step of the assessment.
The two domains people dare not raise
Mood and alcohol weigh heavily on adherence, and almost nobody addresses them at the first session. Two short instruments exist. The PHQ-9 reproduces the nine diagnostic criteria of a depressive episode, scored from 0 to 3. Validated in 6,000 primary care patients, a score of 10 or more gave a sensitivity and specificity of 88 percent for a major depressive episode, with thresholds of 5, 10, 15 and 20 for mild, moderate, moderately severe and severe forms.
The AUDIT-C is limited to the three consumption questions of the full AUDIT. For detecting risky drinking, its area under the curve reached 0.891, slightly better than the full AUDIT at 0.881. Three questions, thirty seconds.
These two tools are not there for the practitioner to make a diagnosis, which is outside their scope. They are there so that a high score triggers a simple sentence and a referral to a physician, rather than the construction of a coaching plan on ground that has not been seen.
What the interview adds compared with the form
One domain resists all questionnaires. The three classic dietary collection methods, 24-hour recall, food diary and food frequency, agree with each other but all diverge from biological markers of intake. Under-reporting of energy is systematic, increases with body mass index, and does not affect all foods the same way, protein being the least under-reported. The authors conclude that self-reported energy intake should not be used to study energy balance.
There remains the way questions are asked. A systematic review published in the BMJ in 2024, covering 97 randomized trials and 27,811 participants, finds a benefit of motivational interviewing on total physical activity, with a standardized difference of 0.45, about 1,323 more steps a day, and 51 minutes less sedentary time.
Two reservations accompany this result and deserve to be stated. No difference appeared against a comparator of equivalent intensity, and the effect faded over time, with the level of evidence judged low to very low. What counts is therefore not the technique displayed but the time actually spent with the person.
Sources
- 1.Buysse DJ, et al. The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index: a new instrument for psychiatric practice and research. Psychiatry Res. 1989.
- 2.Nagappa M, et al. Validation of the STOP-Bang Questionnaire as a Screening Tool for Obstructive Sleep Apnea among Different Populations: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. PLoS One. 2015.
- 3.Chiu HY, et al. Diagnostic accuracy of the Berlin questionnaire, STOP-BANG, STOP, and Epworth sleepiness scale in detecting obstructive sleep apnea: A bivariate meta-analysis. Sleep Med Rev. 2017.
- 4.Craig CL, et al. International physical activity questionnaire: 12-country reliability and validity. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2003.
- 5.Garriguet D, et al. Comparison of Physical Activity Adult Questionnaire results with accelerometer data. Health Rep. 2015.
- 6.Leroux A, et al. NHANES 2011-2014: Objective Physical Activity Is the Strongest Predictor of All-Cause Mortality. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2024.
- 7.Malmstrom TK, et al. SARC-F: a symptom score to predict persons with sarcopenia at risk for poor functional outcomes. J Cachexia Sarcopenia Muscle. 2016.
- 8.Kroenke K, et al. The PHQ-9: validity of a brief depression severity measure. J Gen Intern Med. 2001.
- 9.Bush K, et al. The AUDIT alcohol consumption questions (AUDIT-C): an effective brief screening test for problem drinking. Ambulatory Care Quality Improvement Project (ACQUIP). Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test. Arch Intern Med. 1998.
- 10.Ravelli MN, et al. Traditional Self-Reported Dietary Instruments Are Prone to Inaccuracies and New Approaches Are Needed. Front Nutr. 2020.
- 11.Zhu S, et al. Effectiveness of behavioural interventions with motivational interviewing on physical activity outcomes in adults: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ. 2024.
Reading studies is one thing, turning them into a plan is another
The Longevity Practitioner certification teaches the method that turns this kind of data into an accompaniment decision: assess, prioritise, plan over 90 days, re-measure, and know when to hand over.
11 modules, €2,200. Enrol
Continue reading
Benjamin Sant
Co-founder of the School of Longevity
Cofounder of the School of Longevity with Tristan Maruyama. A former officer trained at Saint-Cyr from 2019 to 2022 and a coach since 2018, he has supported more than 4,000 people. He leads the School's editorial content with one constant principle: pass on only what can be situated, verified and applied seriously.
This article is published for information and education. It does not replace medical advice. For any personal health question, consult a healthcare professional.
